If you're on the hunt for the best caramel popcorn brands, your search can begin and end with Fisher's popcorn. Popping up the most tempting caramel covered popcorn for over 70 years, their recipes are simply unrivaled. For their caramel Old Bay popcorn, they have started with their classic caramel recipe and given it a dusting of Old Bay seasoning. The result? Nothing short of amazing, naturally.