8am-4pm |  Mon-Fri | EST

Reeses Hearts + Gel Icing? Chocolate Conversation Hearts, Of Course!

Reeses Hearts + Gel Icing? Chocolate Conversation Hearts, Of Course!People tend to fall into one of two buckets on Valentine’s Day: love or loathe it. If you love it, you’ll adore it even more when you read our Reeses Hearts recipe! Loathe it? Spend a few minutes whipping up our chocolate conversation hearts, and we think we can convert you into a Valentine’s Day fan! Get ready for the ultimate Valentine’s Day treat. There are so many reasons to love life and the people who make you smile, so toss those old feelings about Valentine’s Day out the window, and let us help you get to know Cupid!

Reeses Hearts with Gel Icing

Makes 36 wrapped chocolate Reeses hearts


· Reeses Hearts – 36 wrapped hearts per bulk

· Gel Icing – choose colors that will really “pop” on the Reeses Hearts, such as white or pastel colors

· Thin icing tips so you can easily write on the Reeses Hearts


1. Visit our Valentine’s Day collection and pick up a box of Reeses Hearts – and oh, maybe another – you’re bound to get a little hungry when creating these treats!

2. Brainstorm cute sayings for the top of each Reeses Heart, including:

a. I Love You

b. Sweet Thing

c. Dreamy

d. Melt

e. Love Bug

f. You Rock

3. Secure the thin icing tips on the gel icing containers. Carefully pen your conversation heart messages on each Reeses Heart.

4. Place the finished Reeses Hearts in the refrigerator for an hour to allow the gel icing to set.

5. Place them in our empty candy boxes, and gift to your loved ones this Valentine’s Day!

Reeses Hearts are made even more delicious with cute gel-icing sayings on them! After all, Valentine’s Day is all about showing the love we have for each other, so why not say it with a creative Reeses Heart?

Sign up for our newsletter
Sign up today and receive all the latest news and biggest discounts on our great candy.
Your privacy is respected
News from the candy blog
Read More
Our Customers Say...

This was our 6th order and the same great service everytime. Love all the new candies this year ... read more

Linda V. Detroit MI. May 2017

View All Testimonials
We Proudly Accept Visa, MasterCard, American Express and Discover. Secure Yahoo! Shopping Internet Retailer second 500 in 2014! Internet Retailer, Hot 100 2011. Best retail Web Sites.
Need Help?
8am-4pm | Mon-Fri | EST