Halloween Candy Showdown: Reese’s Ghosts vs. Reese’s Pumpkins

Every October, our huge candy warehouse transforms into a haunted battleground where seasonal favorites emerge from the shadows. Among the creepiest contenders are two iconic Reese’s creations that only rise from their wrappers once a year: the Reese’s Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Pumpkins and the Reese’s White Crème Peanut Butter Ghosts. Both are loved by trick-or-treaters and candy fanatics, but when placed head-to-head in a Halloween candy showdown, which one truly deserves the crown?

The pumpkins are a familiar sight each fall, with that classic Reese’s combo of milk chocolate and creamy peanut butter. They’re festive, they’re dependable, and they taste just like the Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups we munch on year-round - only dressed up in a pumpkin costume. You know exactly what you’re getting, and chances are you’ll never find a disappointed face when you hand out a pumpkin on Halloween night.

But then, lurking in the shadows, are the white crème ghosts. These spooky shapes don’t just show up in new costumes; they bring a whole new flavor twist to the table. By swapping out the milk chocolate shell for a sweet white crème, Reese’s transforms its classic peanut butter cup into something that feels indulgent and just a little bit eerie. They’re a limited-time treasure that fans anticipate all year long because they’re more than just a shape change - they’re a true reinvention of the classic.

That difference is what makes the debate so fun. The pumpkins are reliable crowd-pleasers, a safe bet that appeals to just about everyone. But the ghosts bring novelty and excitement, making them feel like a special Halloween treat that disappears as quickly as it arrives. For candy lovers who already have access to Reese’s Cups all year, the pumpkins may not feel quite as thrilling, while the ghosts stand out as a seasonal gem worth grabbing before they vanish.

So which one reigns supreme? If you crave tradition with a spooky flair, the pumpkins are your pick. But if you want to taste Halloween magic in its rarest form, the ghosts take the crown. After all, pumpkins may fill your candy bowl with familiarity, but the ghosts haunt your sweet tooth with something unique and unforgettable.

In this Halloween candy showdown, both treats win in their own way, but for many fans, the white crème ghosts hold the true spirit of the season.